From The Vault: Worship Songs That Suck…

2009 July 13
by agathos

Let’s face it the vetting process for “worship” songs just ain’t what it used to be, and even when proper theology was a little more strictly demanded C.S. Lewis still thought of them as fifth rate poetry set to sixth rate music.

If it’s on the radio and gives me an ecstatic feeling while I’m driving in my car seems to be the criteria for some worship leaders today… that and if Chris Tomlin sings it.

Lots of songs are coming out of many different traditions, and not all of them are great. Some songs just suck. Sometimes they suck musically. Sometimes they suck theologically.

So my question for you today is what worship song or songs irritate you–which is kind of ironic–and you would prefer never to have sung at your church again. I’ll get the ball rolling: Our God is an Awesome God.

Now I know this might seem like an odd choice but let me clarify. The chorus is OK and a decent song for churches today, though I would ask what people think when they sing “He reigns from heaven above” and if they may have a too transcendent understanding of God. Then we would have to follow this song with “I’m here to Meet With You Come and Meet with Me” and invite God from “heaven above” to have authority in this place. Seriously, am I the only one that has thoughts like this go through their head during worship?

Those semantics aside: the first verse of “Awesome God” is horrible. In fact, it sucks. I mean have you ever really listened to and thought about this epic piece of crap?

When He rolls up His sleeves
He ain’t just puttin’ on the ritz
(our God is an awesome God)
There is thunder in His footsteps
And lightning in His fist
(our God is an awesome God)
Well, the Lord wasn’t joking
When He kicked ‘em out of Eden
It wasn’t for no reason that He shed his blood
His return is very close and so you better be believing
that our God is an awesome God

It may be that this is the single worst verse ever written in the history of music, which is rather ironic considering how good the chorus is. “When He rolls up His sleeves He ain’t just puttin’ on the ritz” may be the worst line ever written in the worst verse ever written. I wish I had the time to fully deconstruct this foul smelling turd of a verse for you guys. It is bad on so many levels. Bad lazy song writing and weak theology. When will Christians ever learn that the most correct way for us to speak about God is God revealed in Christ? It boggles my mind when the majority of Christians I meet still have pretty much exclusively OT theologies for God, but call themselves followers of Christ. When this happens there is a bifurcation of the godhead that taken to its fullest (and most ridiculous) conclusion looks more like the Westboro Not-Baptist Cult than what I read in the NT.

21 Responses leave one →
  1. 2009 July 13

    Well said! I dislike much of what passes for “praise and worship” these days. I also dislike many hymns that are treasured by the masses. I say this as a committed Southern Baptist who has long been weary of some of the weak theology that permeates “Christian” music.

    As far as modern artists/bands who suck (musically and/or theologically), a few who earn a push of the scan button on the radio are

    Big Daddy Weave
    Third Day (all but about two songs for me)
    Mercy Me
    Chris Tomlin
    Jeremy Camp
    MANY others

    I’m sure I have earned a few extra years in purgatory by being critical of these big-time CCMers, but it’s worth it not to have to listen to them!

  2. 2009 July 13

    For a long time I wondered why people complained so much about ‘Our God Is An Awesome God’. I mean, it’s not the most profound thing in the world, but it’s ok, decent sing-along tune, nothing too offensive.

    Then I discovered it had verses, and I no longer had to wonder.

  3. 2009 July 13
    Michael permalink

    The Jesus-is-my-boyfriend genre is the worst. There are so many directions to go with this one, but I’ll just use the chorus of my personal favorite, “The Power of Your Love”:

    Hold me close/Let your love surround me/Bring me near/Draw me to your side/And as I wait/I’ll rise up like the eagle/And I will soar with you/Your spirit leads me on/In the power of your love

    It is so mindlessly ecstatic, it is close to having sexual undertones.

  4. 2009 July 13

    I totally misremembered this post title as “Worship Song Writers That Suck”!

    (Not thinking of anyone in particular)

  5. 2009 July 13

    I praise the Lord that I have never ever come across the awful bastardy of the song you quote. May he continue to preserve me in peace.

  6. 2009 July 13

    I have enjoyed reading these classic archive posts. I think I dislike the songs that replace “God” with “me” as the center of worship. So the chorus of “History Maker” where I get to sing about how great I am – “I am going to be a history maker in this land, I am going to be a speaker of truth to all mankind, I am going to stand, I am going to run into your arms.” Or the song “Trading my sorrows” which is all about how “oppressed”, “persecuted”, “crushed” or “abandoned” I am (quoting 2 Cor 4:8-9 as if it applied to the free and non-persecuted North American church) but I’m trading it for the joy of the Lord and will now sing “Yes” a million times.

  7. 2009 July 13
    Joshua permalink

    Rich Mullins (who wrote this song) actually regreted having written it and wished that it wouldn’t have been so popular because he felt obligated to play it at almost every concert he performed in his early years. I think by the early nineties he finally quit doing that though. It is undoubtedly his worst song ever. His later stuff is amazing though.

  8. 2009 July 13

    I agree with last comment. Rich Mullins is amazing. That Song is terrible (Although his worst is “Screen Door on a Submarine”).

    I have always had an aversion to “I Could Sing of Your Love Forever” (So just do it then.)

    One of my favorite experiences was when we were singing the song that goes “And I’ll let my words be few…Jesus I am so in love with you.” Ironically, we must have sung those “few” words 10 times over.

  9. 2009 July 13

    And why are most of my friends oblivious to this? oh man, where to begin?

    I Give You My Heart – Michael W. Smith

    Lord I give You my heart.
    I give you my soul.
    I live for You alone
    Every breath that I take
    Every moment I’m awake
    Lord have Your way in me.

    Deeply In Love With You – Kate Spence

    You have stolen my heart
    I’m captivated by You
    Never will You and I part
    I’ve fallen deeply in love with You

    Obsession – David Crowder

    Sometimes you’re further than the moon
    Sometimes you’re closer than my skin
    And you surround me like a winter fog
    You’ve come and burned me with a kiss
    And my heart burns for you
    Yes my heart burns for you
    My heart burns for you
    My heart burns for you

    I Receive You, Oh Spirit Of Love – John Lai

    I can feel You
    I can feel You
    I can feel Your power on me now
    I can feel Your power on me now

    Jesus Take Me As I Am – Dave Bryant

    Jesus take me as I am
    I can come no other way
    Take me deeper into You
    Make my flesh life melt away

    Lord You Put A Tongue In My Mouth – Ian Smale

    Lord, You put a tongue in my mouth
    And I want to sing to You
    Lord, You put a tongue in my mouth
    And I want to sing to You
    Lord, You put a tongue in my mouth
    And I want to sing only to You

    Yes, these songs are just skimming the surface of what is now sung in church. And no, I did not make any of these up. Some lyrics are just bad, and some lyrics are just incredibly unfortunate.

  10. 2009 July 13

    Michael: I agree. In addition I would add that so many songs that plague Christian radio and church song services are somewhat effeminate. I love Christ with all my being, but I find it somewhat strange to sing words like “Jesus I am so in love with you.” It could be the result of growing in an over-sexed generation, or it could be that the songs are just touchy-feely mystic fluff.

  11. 2009 July 14
    Fr Craig permalink

    I’m an episcopal priest, so am not plagued with much of that (through my power over music, and my being an old curmudgeon), but I am frequently asked to permit the use of ‘In the Garden’ at oldsters’ funerals – hate it, talk about sexual undertones! I am also VERY dubious about replacing ‘you’ with ‘me’ or ‘I’, as in ‘I am the bread of life.’
    Love this blog, friend

    • 2009 July 14

      Do you mean “In the Garden of Eden,” by Iron Butterfly? …and old people want it played at their funerals?

      \m/_ That ROCKS! _\m/

      • 2009 July 17
        Fr Craig permalink

        I agree – but the one I hate is the ‘and he walks with me and he talks with me and he tells I am his own…’
        I might agree to Iron Butterfly!!

  12. 2009 July 22
    Ellen permalink

    so why don’t you start with a little of the deconstruction and tell us why it is so bad? Right now you are just doing a bunch of name calling.
    I feel sorry for people who write in the worship music genre. It seems to me, that if the person wants ot make any money in terms of copyright, the song must be very limited in the lyrics and music both. For example, it has to be something people can sing communally and without, say, really long or complicated guitar solos. I was also thinking this last week when I heard someone sing and play and song by Jars of Clay that was poetic and intricate, but for many crowds it would be too edgy, and it was so difficult to get meaning from it by just hearing and reading along (as opposed to being able to go back and read over it).

  13. 2009 August 3

    Weak theology makes weak music but sadly that’s about all that makes up our congregational diet these days. I say this as worshipper, leader and songwriter.

    Now call me heretic, I cannot bring myself to sing Hillsong’s You’ll Come. The chorus bugs me “let your glory fall as you respond to us”. Yeah ok so it’s based on Hosea – as surely as the sun will rise God will come to deliver His people. That’s pre-Jesus no1 and no2, a far cry from God enthroned or inhabiting the praise of His people. So when you continue to stretch that metaphor you are left with an almost demand to God to respond to our praise. Really bothers me.

    I really like the music behind this song but My Glorious also bothers me a bit – what on earth does it mean? “God will save the day (get it) and all will say (yep) my Glorious (huh?)”

    Agree with other sentiment towards the boyfriend songs which are listed above. Other than that, it bothers me to a point that many songs are little more than filler or fluff but that nice melody or cool beat make them must-haves.

  14. 2009 August 10
    Jennifer permalink

    I read Debbie Boone’s autobiography way back when and I think her daddy, Pat, holds a good bit of responsiblity for the boyfriend Jesus songs. She stated something to the effect of and I’m not quoting ver batim because I read this in the early ’80’s…I can sing any song if I can make the words fit Jesus…that’s what her daddy taught her.

  15. 2009 August 10

    Very Interesting article.

  16. 2009 August 10

    Ok you whiners. You don’t like today’s music? YOU write something better! Of all the pathetic things for you crusty collared pathetic whimpering whining Christians to complain about. Give me a break. Fanny Crosby wrote what, 5,000+ songs? We sing, maybe 10? Instead of complaining what you don’t like, why not write about what you DO like? Stop getting your robes in a bunch.

  17. 2009 August 11
    Jake permalink

    You wouldn’t be saying that if you heard some of us sing…

  18. 2009 August 11

    Okay. How’s this:

    “Ichabod take me as I am
    I can come no other way
    Take me deeper into You
    Make my flesh life melt away”

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS